Agenda item

ESCC Consultation: Construction of a new two storey, two form entry primary school including nursery provision with associated parking, 2no. 3G sports pitches, playing surfaces and games court as an extension to the existing school – OLD TOWN.  One letter of objection and one letter of support had been received.

The relevant planning history for the application site and observations of the Specialist Advisor (Arboriculture) and the Specialist Advisor (Planning Policy) were summarised within the report.

Councillor Ungar, Ward Councillor addressed the committee in objection stating that the proposal was strategically in the wrong area of Eastbourne, it would be an overdevelopment of the site and would result in a loss of open space, inadequate parking facilities, and an increase in traffic generation.  There would also be a loss of Elm trees which would be detrimental to the street scene.

Mr Fitzpatrick, Head Teacher, addressed the committee in support stating that the school buildings had not changed since the 1930’s.  A ‘through school’ was supported by both parents and students, with the enquiries for the reception class indicated potential 1/3 enrolment already.  There had been a reduced number of pupils enrolling at the senior level.

Mr Hambrook, ESCC, addressed the committee stating that there had been an increase of 1000+ births year on year in Sussex, which led to an increase in the demand for school placements.  There would be little change in overall numbers of students at the site due to the development of the free school Gildredge House.

NB: Councillor Ungar withdrew from the room whilst this item was considered.

The committee considered the application and acknowledged the need to provide primary school places in Eastbourne however, members felt that this site was inappropriate due to the impact on traffic in and around the school and the increased danger for students.  Members felt that the design was out of keeping with the existing school building.

RESOLVED: (Unanimous) That East Sussex County Council be advised that no objection was raised in principle to the provision of a new school on the site subject to appropriate conditions.  However, concern was raised with regard to the following:

1)   The increased traffic generation and parking within the surrounding roads during pick up and drop off periods and an inappropriate vehicular exit point onto Eldon Road, close to the busy junction with Willingdon Road adding to existing traffic congestion at this junction and consequently within the school grounds.

2)   The adverse impact on surrounding residential amenity with regard to increased on-street parking and traffic, noise and disturbance from the new pedestrian and vehicular access and from Cobbold Road.

3)   The poor quality of design within this prominent location would adversely impact on the appearance and open nature of the site and the street scene.

4)   The loss of playing fields for the existing school within the site which were not adequately replaced or provided elsewhere.

5)   The potential removal of 2 mature Elm Street trees which made a significant contribution to the appearance of the street scene and environmental amenity. The trees were considered a constraint to development and should be retained as part of any redevelopment.